3 Best Pizzerias in Atlanta You Need to Try

From wood-fired classics to creative, star-shaped slices, these Atlanta pizzerias stand out for all the right reasons

Atlanta’s food scene is known for its diversity, and pizza lovers are especially spoiled with standout spots across the city. Whether you’re craving a cozy neighborhood slice, a creative twist on classic pies, or a time-tested favorite that locals swear by, Atlanta delivers. To help narrow it down, here are three of the best pizzerias in Atlanta—each offering a distinct style, unforgettable flavors, and a loyal following.

SunnySide Pizzeria

SunnySide Pizzeria is a favorite for those who appreciate wood-fired pizza in a warm, laid-back setting. Their pies are known for perfectly blistered crusts, balanced toppings, and fresh ingredients that let each flavor shine. While the pizza alone is worth the visit, many regulars insist on saving room for dessert—their tiramisu has earned a reputation as one of the best in the city. It’s the kind of place that feels welcoming whether you’re stopping in for a casual dinner or lingering with friends.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza

Mister O1 stands out for its creative approach to pizza, especially its signature star-shaped pies. These uniquely designed pizzas feature a classic center with star points filled with ricotta and other flavorful ingredients. Known for bold combinations and high-quality toppings, Mister O1 is a go-to spot for diners looking to try something different without sacrificing flavor. It’s a must-visit for anyone who enjoys inventive takes on traditional pizza.

Varasano’s Pizzeria

A long-standing Atlanta favorite, Varasano’s Pizzeria is often praised for its dedication to old-world techniques and quality ingredients. The naturally leavened dough and high-heat baking process create a crisp yet chewy crust that keeps customers coming back. Their pepperoni pizza, in particular, is frequently cited as one of the best in Atlanta. For many locals, Varasano’s represents the gold standard of classic, no-nonsense pizza done right.

Exploring Atlanta’s food scene one slice at a time? These pizzerias are a great place to start. If you’re discovering new neighborhoods, planning a move, or simply want more local recommendations, I’m always happy to help you explore everything Atlanta has to offer.

Q&A

Q1: What style of pizza is most popular in Atlanta?
Atlanta offers a wide range, but wood-fired and Neapolitan-style pizzas are especially popular.

Q2: Are these pizzerias good for casual dining?
Yes, all three spots offer relaxed atmospheres perfect for casual meals.

Q3: Which pizzeria is best for trying something unique?
Mister O1 is known for its star-shaped pizzas and creative flavor combinations.

Q4: Is Varasano’s good for traditional pizza lovers?
Absolutely. Varasano’s is ideal for those who appreciate classic techniques and simple, high-quality ingredients.

Q5: Do these pizzerias offer dessert options?
Yes—SunnySide Pizzeria, in particular, is well known for its tiramisu.

If you’re exploring Atlanta neighborhoods, moving for work, or curious how this growth impacts real estate, I’m here to help guide you.

I’m Nadine Lutz, one of Atlanta's top Realtors and a trusted Atlanta, Georgia Real Estate Agent with Compass Buckhead, and Atlanta has been home to my family since 2003. Over the years, I’ve been blessed to help so many neighbors achieve their real estate goals, and I’m honored to be recognized with the Phoenix Award and as a Multi-Million Dollar Club Life Member with the Atlanta Realtors Association.

Awards aside, what matters most to me is guiding people through one of the biggest decisions of their lives with honesty, care, and local expertise. If you’re ready to explore Atlanta homes for sale or make your next move, I’d be grateful for the chance to help.